Xero vs MYOB vs QuickBooks: Which Is Right for Your Business?

Choosing accounting software isn't just about finding the cheapest option or the one with the most features. It's about finding the platform that fits your business operations, supports your growth, and makes financial management genuinely easier rather than adding another layer of complexity. For Australian business owners, this decision carries additional weight because the right software needs to handle local compliance requirements like GST, BAS, and Single Touch Payroll seamlessly.

Three platforms dominate the Australian market: Xero, MYOB, and QuickBooks. Each has carved out its own strengths, attracted loyal followings, and evolved to meet changing business needs. But which one is right for your business? This comprehensive comparison cuts through the marketing noise to help you make an informed decision based on what actually matters for your operations.

The Current Market Landscape in Australia

The accounting software market in Australia has undergone dramatic transformation over the past decade. Where MYOB once commanded over 80% market share as the traditional desktop accounting leader, the landscape has shifted decisively toward cloud-based solutions.

As of 2025, Xero has established clear dominance with over 60% market share, while MYOB maintains approximately 20-25% of the online accounting market. QuickBooks, backed by Intuit's global presence, continues growing its Australian presence but remains behind the two local leaders.

Among accounting professionals, Xero captures 55.14% of accountant click share compared to MYOB's 17.15% and QuickBooks' 8.03%. This preference among accountants matters because it affects how easily you'll collaborate with your accounting professional and access expert support.

Understanding this landscape helps explain why certain features have developed the way they have and where each platform focuses its development efforts. Let's examine each platform in detail.

1. Xero: The Cloud-Native Leader

Founded in New Zealand in 2006 and now headquartered in Melbourne, Xero built its entire platform around cloud technology from day one. This cloud-first approach has made it the platform of choice for businesses that value accessibility, collaboration, and modern user experience.

What Xero Does Well:

• User-Friendly Interface: Xero consistently receives praise for its clean, intuitive design. Even business owners without accounting backgrounds find it straightforward to navigate. The dashboard provides clear financial snapshots, and creating invoices or reconciling transactions feels natural rather than cumbersome.

• Unlimited Users: One of Xero's standout features is unlimited user access across all plans from Standard upwards. This means your bookkeeper, accountant, business partner, and team members can all access the system simultaneously without additional user fees. For growing businesses or those who value collaboration, this flexibility is invaluable.

• Extensive Integration Ecosystem: Xero offers over 800 third-party integrations, connecting with everything from point-of-sale systems and inventory management tools to CRM platforms and project management software. This extensive marketplace means you can build a complete business management system around Xero as your financial hub.

• Strong Bank Reconciliation: Xero's automated bank feeds connect directly to your financial institutions, importing transactions daily. The reconciliation process uses smart matching to suggest likely categories based on your historical patterns, significantly reducing manual data entry.

• Mobile Accessibility: The Xero mobile app provides genuine functionality, not just a stripped-down version. You can create and send invoices, capture receipt photos, approve bills, and check your financial position from anywhere—genuinely useful for business owners constantly on the move.

• Accountant-Friendly: The platform's popularity among accounting professionals means finding a Xero-savvy accountant or bookkeeper is straightforward. The practice manager features facilitate smooth collaboration between businesses and their advisors.

  
  

Xero's Limitations:

• Payroll Costs Add Up: While Xero's base plans are competitively priced, payroll is an additional cost. For businesses with employees, you'll need to factor in payroll fees on top of your subscription, which can make the total investment higher than initially apparent.

• Transaction Limits on Entry Plans: The Starter plan caps you at 20 invoices and 20 bills monthly, with reconciliation for 20 bank transactions. While this suits very small operations, most businesses outgrow these limits quickly and need to upgrade.

• Learning Curve for Advanced Features: While basic functions are intuitive, accessing more sophisticated capabilities like tracking categories, fixed assets, or multi-currency transactions requires deeper exploration. The simplicity that makes Xero accessible can sometimes hide more powerful features.

• Limited Offline Functionality: As a cloud-native platform, Xero requires internet connectivity. For businesses in areas with unreliable internet or those who prefer offline access, this dependency can be frustrating.

  
  

Xero Pricing Structure (2025)

Xero offers several tiers to suit different business stages:

• Starter Plan (~$30/month): Suitable for sole traders with minimal transactions. Includes 20 invoices, 5 bills, 1 payroll employee, and 20 bank transaction reconciliations monthly. Payroll requires separate add-on.

• Standard Plan (~$60/month): The sweet spot for most small businesses. Removes transaction limits for invoices, bills, and bank reconciliations. Includes Hubdoc for receipt capture. Payroll still requires additional fee.

• Premium Plans: Higher-tier options include enhanced features like multi-currency support, expense claims, and increased payroll capacity. Pricing scales based on specific requirements.

  
  

Best Suited For

Xero excels for service-based businesses, consultants, freelancers, creative agencies, and any business valuing collaboration and modern user experience. It's particularly strong for businesses with remote or distributed teams who need simultaneous access, and for those who rely heavily on third-party integrations to connect various business systems.

2. MYOB: The Australian Veteran

Established in 1991, MYOB (Mind Your Own Business) has been serving Australian businesses longer than its competitors. This heritage means deep understanding of local compliance requirements and a loyal user base, particularly among traditional industries.

What MYOB Does Well:

• Australian Compliance Excellence: MYOB provides deep integration with Australian Tax Office systems, automating GST calculations, BAS preparation, and superannuation tracking to ensure compliance. For businesses with complex Australian tax obligations, this specialized focus provides confidence and reduces compliance risks.

• Advanced Payroll Capabilities: MYOB's payroll system handles complex award rates, leave tracking, and superannuation with particular sophistication. Industries with complicated payroll requirements—like healthcare, construction, or hospitality with multiple award classifications—find MYOB's capabilities especially valuable.

• Robust Inventory Management: For product-based businesses, MYOB offers comprehensive inventory features including multi-location tracking, low stock warnings, and detailed cost accounting. The AccountRight versions provide particularly sophisticated inventory capabilities that exceed what Xero or QuickBooks offer in their standard packages.

• Hybrid Cloud-Desktop Options: Unlike purely cloud-based competitors, MYOB offers both cloud and desktop solutions. The AccountRight range provides desktop software that can sync to the cloud, appealing to businesses preferring local data storage or needing offline access.

• Established Support Network: Decades of operation mean extensive local support resources, including certified partners, training providers, and a deep pool of MYOB-experienced bookkeepers and accountants across Australia.

MYOB's Limitations:

• Ease of use: MYOB retains more traditional accounting terminology and workflows, requiring more initial training compared to Xero's simplified interface. This steeper learning curve can frustrate business owners without accounting backgrounds.

• Integrations: MYOB offers fewer third-party integrations compared to Xero (800+) and QuickBooks (650+), which may limit workflow automation for businesses using specialized apps. This smaller ecosystem can restrict how well MYOB connects with other business tools.

• Complex Product Lines: MYOB's range includes Business Essentials, Business Pro, AccountRight Plus, and AccountRight Premier. Understanding which product suits your needs and what features each tier offers creates confusion compared to competitors' simpler tiering.

• Transition Challenges: AccountRight Plus and Premier require desktop software installation for advanced features like multi-currency support, time billing, and comprehensive inventory management, necessitating manual updates across all users. This hybrid approach can create technical challenges and inconsistent user experiences.

MYOB Pricing Structure (2025)

MYOB's pricing varies significantly across product lines:

Business Essentials (~$34/month): Cloud-based entry-level plan with simplified interface. Good for very small businesses with basic needs.

Business Pro (~$55/month): Includes unlimited bank connections and payroll for unlimited employees at additional per-employee fees.

AccountRight Plus (~$136/month): Desktop-cloud hybrid with advanced inventory, project billing, and comprehensive payroll.

AccountRight Premier (~$170/month): Top-tier solution with multi-location warehousing, multi-currency, and full feature access.

Best Suited For

MYOB works particularly well for traditional Australian businesses with complex payroll needs (tradies, construction companies, manufacturing), retailers with sophisticated inventory requirements, established businesses comfortable with traditional accounting workflows, and organizations preferring hybrid cloud-desktop solutions or requiring offline access.

3. QuickBooks: The Global Contender

Developed by Intuit and commanding dominant market share globally (especially in the United States), QuickBooks entered the Australian market later than its competitors but has been steadily growing its presence. It brings international expertise and competitive pricing to challenge the local leaders.

What QuickBooks Does Well:

• Competitive Pricing: QuickBooks often presents the most affordable entry point. With plans starting around $29/month and frequent promotional offers providing significant discounts for new subscribers, it appeals strongly to cost-conscious small businesses.

• Comprehensive Reporting: QuickBooks offers particularly detailed and customizable financial reports. The reporting tools provide deep insights into business performance without requiring accounting expertise to interpret, helping owners make data-driven decisions.

• Strong Expense Tracking: The mobile app excels at expense capture, allowing you to photograph receipts, automatically extract data, and categorize expenses on the go. This feature proves especially valuable for businesses with significant expense tracking needs.

• Inventory Management: For product-based businesses, QuickBooks provides solid inventory tracking capabilities that balance sophistication with usability. The system handles stock levels, cost of goods sold, and reordering efficiently.

• Global Payment Integration: With over 25 payment processor integrations, QuickBooks makes it easy to accept payments through various channels. The global nature of the platform means strong support for international transactions and multi-currency operations.

• Excellent Customer Support: QuickBooks provides unlimited phone and chat support across its plans, often with faster response times than competitors. For businesses that value accessible support, this comprehensive assistance proves valuable.

QuickBooks' Limitations:

• User Limits: Unlike Xero's unlimited users, QuickBooks restricts access based on plan level. Simple Start allows only one user, Essentials permits three, and Plus accommodates five. For collaborative teams or businesses working closely with external advisors, these restrictions become frustrating limitations.

• Steeper Learning Curve: While powerful, QuickBooks can feel overwhelming to newcomers. The extensive features and granular settings require more time to learn and configure effectively compared to Xero's streamlined approach.

• Less Popular Among Australian Accountants: With lower market share among accounting professionals in Australia, finding a QuickBooks-specialized accountant may prove more challenging than locating Xero or MYOB experts.

• Australian Compliance: While QuickBooks handles Australian tax requirements adequately, it doesn't have the same depth of local compliance features that MYOB offers, reflecting its international rather than Australia-specific development focus.

QuickBooks Pricing Structure (2025)

QuickBooks offers competitive tiering:

• Simple Start (~$29/month): Basic features for sole traders. Includes invoicing, expense tracking, basic reporting, and one user.

• Essentials (~$40/month): Adds bill management, up to three users, and more comprehensive reporting.

• Plus (~$55/month): Includes inventory tracking, project management, up to five users, and advanced features.

Payroll typically costs an additional $5 per employee monthly across all plans.

Best Suited For

QuickBooks works well for budget-conscious startups prioritizing affordability, product-based businesses needing solid inventory management, companies requiring detailed financial reporting and analysis, businesses with international transactions or multi-currency needs, and sole traders or small teams not requiring many simultaneous users.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Key Decision Factors

1. Ease of Use

Winner: Xero

Xero's clean interface and intuitive navigation make it the easiest platform for non-accountants to adopt. QuickBooks offers powerful features but with more complexity, while MYOB's traditional accounting terminology presents the steepest learning curve.

2. Australian Tax Compliance

Winner: MYOB

While all three platforms handle GST, BAS, and Single Touch Payroll adequately, MYOB's deep ATO integration and specialized Australian compliance tools give it the edge for businesses with complex tax obligations.

3. Pricing Value

Winner: QuickBooks (entry-level), Xero (growing businesses)

QuickBooks offers the lowest entry price point, making it attractive for startups. However, when factoring in user limits and scalability, Xero's unlimited users and transparent pricing often provide better value as businesses grow.

4. Integration Ecosystem

Winner: Xero

With over 800 integrations compared to QuickBooks' 650+ and MYOB's more limited options, Xero provides the most flexibility for connecting with other business tools and building comprehensive management systems.

5. Payroll Capabilities

Winner: MYOB

For businesses with complex payroll needs, especially those dealing with multiple awards, detailed leave tracking, or sophisticated superannuation requirements, MYOB's advanced payroll features are unmatched.

6. Collaboration and Multi-User Access

Winner: Xero

Unlimited users across standard plans make Xero ideal for teams, businesses working with external advisors, or companies expecting growth in staff numbers.

7. Mobile Functionality

Winner: Tie (Xero/QuickBooks)

Both Xero and QuickBooks offer robust mobile apps with comprehensive functionality. MYOB's mobile experience is adequate but less refined.

8. Inventory Management

Winner: MYOB (advanced needs), QuickBooks (standard needs)

MYOB's AccountRight solutions provide the most sophisticated inventory features for complex operations. For standard inventory tracking, QuickBooks offers the best balance of capability and usability.

9. Reporting and Analytics

Winner: QuickBooks

QuickBooks excels in report customization and depth of financial analysis, providing particularly detailed insights that support data-driven decision-making.

10. Offline Access

Winner: MYOB

MYOB's hybrid desktop-cloud options provide genuine offline functionality, whereas Xero and QuickBooks require internet connectivity for core operations.

Industry-Specific Recommendations

1. Service-Based Businesses (Consultants, Agencies, Professional Services)

Recommended: Xero

Service businesses benefit most from Xero's collaboration features, unlimited users, and extensive integration options. The clean interface makes it easy for non-financial team members to create invoices or track time, while the mobile app supports on-the-go management.

2. Retail and E-Commerce

Recommended: QuickBooks or MYOB

Retail businesses need solid inventory management. QuickBooks provides excellent inventory features at competitive pricing, while MYOB offers more advanced capabilities for multi-location or complex inventory needs. Both platforms integrate well with point-of-sale systems.

3. Construction and Trades

Recommended: MYOB

The construction industry's complex payroll requirements, including multiple award rates and detailed cost tracking, make MYOB's specialized capabilities particularly valuable. The platform's project costing features also suit trades businesses tracking profitability across multiple jobs.

4. Hospitality and Tourism

Recommended: Xero or MYOB

Hospitality businesses benefit from Xero's user-friendly interface and strong POS integrations. However, businesses with complex payroll needs (multiple award rates, casual loading, split shifts) may find MYOB's payroll capabilities more suitable.

5. Healthcare and Professional Practices

Recommended: Xero

Medical, dental, and allied health practices typically have straightforward accounting needs but value easy collaboration with practice managers, accountants, and multiple practitioners. Xero's unlimited users and clean interface suit these requirements well.

6. Manufacturing and Distribution

Recommended: MYOB

Manufacturing businesses requiring sophisticated inventory management, multi-location tracking, and detailed cost accounting benefit from MYOB AccountRight's advanced features that exceed what Xero or QuickBooks offer in standard packages.

Making Your Decision: A Practical Framework

Choosing between these platforms ultimately comes down to your specific business circumstances. Here's a framework to guide your decision:

Choose Xero If You:

• Value ease of use and modern user experience above all else

• Need multiple team members or external advisors to access your accounts simultaneously

• Want extensive third-party integrations to connect various business tools

• Prefer cloud-native solutions with strong mobile functionality

• Work primarily in service-based industries without complex inventory needs

• Want accounting software most Australian accountants are already familiar with

  
  

Choose MYOB If You:

• Have complex Australian compliance requirements you want automated

• Require sophisticated payroll capabilities handling multiple awards and detailed tracking

• Need advanced inventory management with multi-location warehousing

• Prefer hybrid cloud-desktop solutions or require offline access

• Work in traditional industries like construction, manufacturing, or retail

• Value long-established Australian support networks and local expertise

Choose QuickBooks If You:

• Prioritize affordability and want the lowest entry-level pricing

• Need detailed, customizable financial reporting and analysis

• Require strong inventory management at competitive pricing

• Handle significant international transactions or multi-currency operations

• Have a small team (under five users) and don't need extensive collaboration

• Value comprehensive customer support with unlimited phone and chat access

Important Considerations Beyond Features

Your Accountant's Preference: If you work with an accountant or bookkeeper, their platform expertise matters significantly. Forcing them to use unfamiliar software creates inefficiency and may limit the quality of advice they can provide.

Data Migration: Switching platforms later involves time, cost, and potential data loss. While all three offer migration services, choosing correctly from the start saves considerable hassle.

Growth Trajectory: Consider not just your current needs but where your business is heading. Will you need more users? More sophisticated features? International capabilities? Choose software that can grow with you rather than requiring replacement.

Industry Networks: Some industries have strong preferences for particular platforms. Fellow business owners in your sector can provide valuable insights about what works well for your specific circumstances.

Trial All Three: Every platform offers free trials. Actually using the software reveals whether it matches your work style better than any feature comparison can. Invest time in genuine trials before committing.

Getting Started: Implementation Best Practices

Whichever platform you choose, proper implementation sets you up for success:

• Clean Up Your Data First

• Plan Your Chart of Accounts

• Set Up Automation

• Train Your Team

• Connect Your Integrations

• Work With Professionals

Click here for more information

Need help choosing the right accounting software for your business?  At LK Accounting & Advisory, we work with Xero, MYOB, and QuickBooks daily. We can assess your specific needs, recommend the best platform for your circumstances, and help with setup and training to ensure you get maximum value from your investment. Contact us today for expert guidance tailored to your business.

LK Accounting & Advisory provides professional bookkeeping, accounting, and business advisory services to businesses across Australia. Our team has extensive experience implementing and supporting all major accounting software platforms, helping clients choose and optimize the systems that work best for their unique needs.